Skip to content
Magical Mystery Media Magical Mystery Media

The Stories We Tell in the Dark

  • Magical Mystery Media
  • Film on the Fringe
  • Apple Podcasts
  • Contact
  • About
  • Olive Thomas
Magical Mystery Media
Magical Mystery Media

The Stories We Tell in the Dark

THE CONJURING: LAST RITES, Smurl Haunting True Story, ANNABELLE is Real!

Posted on By

Before and after seeing The Conjuring: Last Rites, Adam explores the real Smurl Haunting, revisits his personal Warren family connection, and breaks down what the movie got right – and what it invented.

Part One: The Real Story
Before seeing the movie, Adam discusses:

  • The real Smurl Haunting: What Jack and Janet Smurl claimed they experienced in 1970s Pennsylvania.

  • Why the Warrens may never have walked away from a case – and what that says about their credibility.

Part Two: The Movie Reaction
After watching the film, Adam offers a spoiler-lite reaction and compares fact vs. fiction:

  • Which scenes were adapted from the Smurl claims.

  • How The Conjuring timeline ignores real-world chronology.

  • How the film shifts the focus to Judy Warren and her boyfriend Tony – who, yes, is a real person.

  • What the movie omits: the shadowy entities and other key details from the Smurl case.

Also in this episode:

  • The real Raggedy Ann “Annabelle” vs. her porcelain cinematic doppelgänger.

  • The Warrens’ controversial museum and the myths surrounding cursed objects.

  • One person’s ill-fated encounter with the cursed doll.

  • A recent and eerie real-world death linked to the Annabelle legend.

  • How The Conjuring universe continues to grow – with an upcoming HBO spinoff on the horizon.

This episode blends folklore, true crime, horror history, and a healthy dose of skepticism.

NEWS FLASH: The Warren museum has been purchased by comedian Matt Rife and YouTuber Elton Castee.

Magical Mystery Media

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post
Copyright 2025 MagicalMystery.Media